The ItaloTurkish war 191112 Italy Esercito Corpo Di Stato Maggiore 9781177287890 Books
Download As PDF : The ItaloTurkish war 191112 Italy Esercito Corpo Di Stato Maggiore 9781177287890 Books
This is a reproduction of a book published before 1923. This book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages, poor pictures, errant marks, etc. that were either part of the original artifact, or were introduced by the scanning process. We believe this work is culturally important, and despite the imperfections, have elected to bring it back into print as part of our continuing commitment to the preservation of printed works worldwide. We appreciate your understanding of the imperfections in the preservation process, and hope you enjoy this valuable book.
The ItaloTurkish war 191112 Italy Esercito Corpo Di Stato Maggiore 9781177287890 Books
I was disappointed in this book. I bought it to do some research in aspects of the Italo-Turkish War. I knew it was a scan of a 1914 work by US Marine Corps 1st Lieutenant Renato Titoni, who had been an observer with the Italian forces. He said that he used offlcial Italian military reporting because he found the uber-patriotism of the Italian press had distorted events so much. That's commendable, but if this was an improvement, I'd hate to have seen the press version. Without going into detail, the propaganda of the Italian Government and jingosim of the Italian press made the invasion seem like a done deal from the outset, a sure thing in which a dying Ottoman Emprie gave up its turf to a newly invigorated Kingdom of Italy.It didn't quite work out that way, but the Italian forces did win. Given that the Italians had 100,000 regular troops, modern naval vessels and artillery against shore batteries, and aircraft, and that they faced 8,000 Turkish regulars and about 20,00 local Arab levies, with no means of supply, it should have been a piece of cake. It wasn't. The Ottoman Empire was so destitute that officers on leave in Turkey had to pay their own way back and then be smuggled into Libya to rejoin their units. They fought - hard - and several commanders were noted for their leadership. Mustafa Kemal, later to be known as Ataturk, was one of these. Eventually, however, the Italian forces prevailed.
The problem is that this particular report is little more than a PR piece for the Italian forces. Their leaders were "brilliant," their troops were "valiant," their bivouac conditions were "excellent," the fighting was "fierce," but the Italian forces were "resolute." This is not to suggest the opposite is true. Like most wars, the performance of each side offers examples of great courage and stellar leadership, mixed with timidity and indecisiveness. It would have been much more useful if they at least addressed this in oblique terms, but after the glorious war demanded by the press, perhaps that was simply not going to happen.
The other problem I have with this book has more modern roots. Like most such products where they are mostly gleaning the efforts of authors long since dead whose copyright has expired, it contains the standard warning that "this book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages, poor pictures, errant marks, etc. that were either part of the original work or were introduced by the scanning process." Unfortunately, having examined all the photos and illustrations, I am reasonably certain that the flaws were caused by someone who either didn't know or didn't care how to scan properly. It's a pity, because there is some interesting visual material in the book, but it looks like it was photographed through a wet glass shower door.
This is perhaps valuable as an example of early 20th century ex post facto progaganda, but you will find more useful information from Wikipedia.
Product details
|
Tags : The Italo-Turkish war (1911-12.) [Italy. Esercito. Corpo Di Stato Maggiore] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. This is a reproduction of a book published before 1923. This book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages,Italy. Esercito. Corpo Di Stato Maggiore,The Italo-Turkish war (1911-12.),Nabu Press,1177287897,General,History,History - General History,History General
People also read other books :
- Ransom Dreams A Novel of Psychological Dread eBook Robert Bucchianeri
- Cheer Up Your Wife edition by Aleathea Dupree Religion Spirituality eBooks
- Be More Better Stuff to Know and Use Volume 1 Michael J Czuchnicki Joseph Milano Theresa Swala 9780988357815 Books
- Almost Over It Clover Park STUDS Book 1 edition by Kylie Gilmore Literature Fiction eBooks
- Trieste Italian Edition Giulio Caprin 9781141604685 Books
The ItaloTurkish war 191112 Italy Esercito Corpo Di Stato Maggiore 9781177287890 Books Reviews
I was disappointed in this book. I bought it to do some research in aspects of the Italo-Turkish War. I knew it was a scan of a 1914 work by US Marine Corps 1st Lieutenant Renato Titoni, who had been an observer with the Italian forces. He said that he used offlcial Italian military reporting because he found the uber-patriotism of the Italian press had distorted events so much. That's commendable, but if this was an improvement, I'd hate to have seen the press version. Without going into detail, the propaganda of the Italian Government and jingosim of the Italian press made the invasion seem like a done deal from the outset, a sure thing in which a dying Ottoman Emprie gave up its turf to a newly invigorated Kingdom of Italy.
It didn't quite work out that way, but the Italian forces did win. Given that the Italians had 100,000 regular troops, modern naval vessels and artillery against shore batteries, and aircraft, and that they faced 8,000 Turkish regulars and about 20,00 local Arab levies, with no means of supply, it should have been a piece of cake. It wasn't. The Ottoman Empire was so destitute that officers on leave in Turkey had to pay their own way back and then be smuggled into Libya to rejoin their units. They fought - hard - and several commanders were noted for their leadership. Mustafa Kemal, later to be known as Ataturk, was one of these. Eventually, however, the Italian forces prevailed.
The problem is that this particular report is little more than a PR piece for the Italian forces. Their leaders were "brilliant," their troops were "valiant," their bivouac conditions were "excellent," the fighting was "fierce," but the Italian forces were "resolute." This is not to suggest the opposite is true. Like most wars, the performance of each side offers examples of great courage and stellar leadership, mixed with timidity and indecisiveness. It would have been much more useful if they at least addressed this in oblique terms, but after the glorious war demanded by the press, perhaps that was simply not going to happen.
The other problem I have with this book has more modern roots. Like most such products where they are mostly gleaning the efforts of authors long since dead whose copyright has expired, it contains the standard warning that "this book may have occasional imperfections such as missing or blurred pages, poor pictures, errant marks, etc. that were either part of the original work or were introduced by the scanning process." Unfortunately, having examined all the photos and illustrations, I am reasonably certain that the flaws were caused by someone who either didn't know or didn't care how to scan properly. It's a pity, because there is some interesting visual material in the book, but it looks like it was photographed through a wet glass shower door.
This is perhaps valuable as an example of early 20th century ex post facto progaganda, but you will find more useful information from Wikipedia.
0 Response to "[H5T]∎ PDF Gratis The ItaloTurkish war 191112 Italy Esercito Corpo Di Stato Maggiore 9781177287890 Books"
Post a Comment